Debitirali u studenome 2012. na Survivor Series PPV-u, i od tada su bili prikazani kao najbolji trios stable ikada. Redom su padali, Jericho, Cena, Big Show, The Undertaker, Wyatt Family... U feudu s Authorityem Seth Rollins im je okrenuo leđa i pridružio se Authorityu. Grupa se raspala 2014.-te, da bi se reunitala 2017.-te na kratko i 2018.-te, ali su se opet raspali nakon što je Roman morao odustati privremeno od wrestlinga jer je objavio da je bolestan, a Ambrose je napravio heel turn nad Rollinsom.
NXT Championship 1x (Seth Rollins)
WWE Intercontinental Championship 2x (Reigns 1x) (Rollins 1x)
WWE RAW Tag Team Championship 3x (Reigns & Rollins 1x) (Rollins & Ambrose 2x)
WWE US Championship 1x (Dean Ambrose)
WWE Universal Championship 1x (Roman Reigns)
Slammy Awards 5x
- Breakout Star of the Year (2013)
- Faction of the Year (2013, 2014)
- Trending Now (Hashtag of the Year 2013) - #BelieveInTheShield
- "What a Maneuver" of the Year (2013) - Reigns Spear
WON Most Improved (2013) - Roman Reigns
WON Tag Team of the Year (2013) Rollins & Reigns
PWI Tag Team of the Year (2013) Rollins & Reigns
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Započeli kao tag team u Ring of Honouru 2014.-te godine, a nastupali su za NJPW i druge indy kompanije. Početkom 2018.-te potpisuju ugovor s WWE-om i prelaze u NXT brand.
BCW Tag Team Championship 1x
IWGP Tag Team Championship 2x
ROH World Tag Team Championship 1x
VIP Tag Team Championship 1x
WCPW Tag Team Championship 1x